Should Sugar be Regulated like Alcohol and Tobacco?

By Bonnie Rochman | ARK Insurance Solutions

Scientists at the University of California, San Francisco, argue that sugar is toxic and needs to be taxed and controlled. Why it’s so hard to break our addiction.

Sugar poses enough health risks that it should be considered a controlled substance just like alcohol and tobacco, contend a team of researchers from the University of California, San Francisco (UCSF).

In an opinion piece called “The Toxic Truth About Sugar” that was published Feb. 1 in the journal Nature, Robert Lustig, Laura Schmidt and Claire Brindis argue that it’s a misnomer to consider sugar just “empty calories.” They write: “There is nothing empty about these calories. A growing body of scientific evidence is showing that fructose can trigger processes that lead to liver toxicity and a host of other chronic diseases. A little is not a problem, but a lot kills — slowly.”

Almost everyone’s heard of — or personally experienced — the proverbial sugar high, so perhaps the comparison between sugar and alcohol or tobacco shouldn’t come as a surprise. But it’s doubtful that Americans will look favorably upon regulating their favorite vice. We’re a nation that’s sweet on sugar: the average U.S. adult downs 22 teaspoons of sugar a day, according to the American Heart Association, and surveys have found that teens swallow 34 teaspoons.

To counter our consumption, the authors advocate taxing sugary foods and controlling sales to kids under 17. Already, 17% of U.S. children and teens are obese, and across the world the sugar intake has tripled in the past 50 years. The increase has helped create a global obesity pandemic that contributes to 35 million annual deaths worldwide from noninfectious diseases including diabetes, heart disease and cancer.

“There are good calories and bad calories, just as there are good fats and bad fats, good amino acids and bad amino acids, good carbohydrates and bad carbohydrates,” Lustig, a professor of pediatrics and director of the Weight Assessment for Teen and Child Health (WATCH) program at UCSF, said in a statement. “But sugar is toxic beyond its calories.”

The food industry tries to imply that “a calorie is a calorie,” says Kelly Brownell, director of the Rudd Center for Food Policy and Obesity at Yale University. “But this and other research suggests there is something different about sugar,” says Brownell.

(MORE: Ads Featuring Overweight Children Make Some Experts Uncomfortable)

The UCSF report emphasizes the metabolic effects of sugar. Excess sugar can alter metabolism, raise blood pressure, skew the signaling of hormones and damage the liver — outcomes that sound suspiciously similar to what can happen after a person drinks too much alcohol. Schmidt, co-chair of UCSF’s Community Engagement and Health Policy program, noted on CNN: “When you think about it, this actually makes a lot of sense. Alcohol, after all, is simply the distillation of sugar. Where does vodka come from? Sugar.”

But there are also other areas of impact that researchers have investigated: the effect of sugar on the brain and how liquid calories are interpreted differently by the body than solids. Research has suggested that sugar activates the same reward pathways in the brain as traditional drugs of abuse like morphine or heroin. No one is claiming the effect of sugar is quite that potent, but, says Brownell, “it helps confirm what people tell you anecdotally, that they crave sugar and have withdrawal symptoms when they stop eating it.”

There’s also something particularly insidious about sugary beverages. “When calories come in liquids, the body doesn’t feel as full,” says Brownell. “People are getting more of their calories than ever before from sugared beverages.”

Other countries, including France, Greece and Denmark, levy soda taxes, and the concept is being considered in at least 20 U.S. cities and states. Last summer, Philadelphia came close to passing a 2-cents-per-ounce soda tax. The Rudd Center has been a vocal proponent of a more modest 1-cent-per-ounce tax. But at least one study, from 2010, has raised doubts that soda taxes would result in significant weight loss: apparently people who are determined to eat — and drink — unhealthily will find ways to do it.

(MORE: Banning Sugared Drinks in Schools Doesn’t Lower Student Consumption)

Ultimately, regulating sugar will prove particularly tricky because it transcends health concerns; sugar, for so many people, is love. A plate of cut-up celery just doesn’t pack the same emotional punch as a tin of homemade chocolate chip cookies, which is why I took my daughter for a cake pop and not an apple as an after-school treat today. We don’t do that regularly — it’s the first time this school year, actually — and that’s what made it special. As a society, could we ever reach the point where we’d think apples — not cake on a stick — are something to get excited over? Says Brindis, one of the report’s authors and director of UCSF’s Philip R. Lee Institute for Health Policy Studies: “We recognize that there are cultural and celebratory aspects of sugar. Changing these patterns is very complicated.”

For inroads to be made, say the authors in their statement, people have to be better educated about the hazards of sugar and agree that something’s got to change:

Many of the interventions that have reduced alcohol and tobacco consumption can be models for addressing the sugar problem, such as levying special sales taxes, controlling access, and tightening licensing requirements on vending machines and snack bars that sell high sugar products in schools and workplaces.

“We’re not talking prohibition,” Schmidt said. “We’re not advocating a major imposition of the government into people’s lives. We’re talking about gentle ways to make sugar consumption slightly less convenient, thereby moving people away from the concentrated dose. What we want is to actually increase people’s choices by making foods that aren’t loaded with sugar comparatively easier and cheaper to get.”

Leave a Comment





...with powerful health care and claims management systems to save them money.
We believe your investment in a health plan should be treated like any other aspect of your business, with upfront knowledge of the costs and all attempts to weed out waste. MBA saves employers more than nickels and dimes with many methods of management, including: Metrics Based Pricing: Why rejoice over a 30% discount on a claim that is 1000% too high? Metrics Based Pricing reduces claims to a “cost of service + reasonable margin” level by auditing claims for unfair markups and inaccurate or fraudulent billing. This results in an average $1500 per employee savings – AND WE DO IT WITHOUT RESTRICTIVE NETWORKS! Medical Management Services: Proven to reduce hospital admissions and the average length of stay. HealthSteps™: Wellness plans and initiatives that do make a difference in the overall health of your workforce and drive down health claims. Prescription Benefit Management: With an average reduction of 9.4%. Internet Prescription Bidding: Allowing employees to save up to 87%. Actuarial Projecting: The projection of benefit costs and savings is one of our underwriting core competencies. Go ahead – suggest benefit changes, add or drop a plan component, change eligibility: MBA will accurately determine the financial impact on the plan and offer suggestions to tweak the benefits to suit your objectives. We offer the facts then you call the shots.
×
We're neighbors you can talk to...
Where else can you get a direct line to a claims adjudicator, plan manager or even the President of the company? Only at MBA Benefit Administrators. We’re the big third party administrator for health plans with personal service that you can only wish others would provide. Like talking to a friend over a fence, we have that neighborly feel…but we provide world class advantages.
×
With “outside the box” flexibility in health plan administration…
Since 1987 MBA Benefit Administrators has successfully served large and small employers, public entities, associations, tribal nations, school districts, non-profit organizations and insurers. We have the capability to administer anything from single-plan 25-life groups to complex employee organizations with multiple medical, dental and vision benefits or employees in multiple states. We also provide a wide array of ancillary services such as COBRA and HIPAA administration and HSAs. When you discover:

  • The depth of our experience
  • The flexibility we offer in benefit design
  • Our commitment to technology to make your life easier
  • Our can-do attitude toward service

 

…we’re confident you too will see why MBA is a national leader in third party administrative healthcare benefits.

×
…and we prove real solutions do exist for escalating healthcare costs.
We’ve received national kudos for our multiple, proven strategies which reduce claims and plan costs without harmful benefit reductions for our clients’ employees. Proof of MBA’s effectiveness in this is in the numbers. Our clients see:

  • An immediate average reduction of up to 25% in maximum health plan costs the first year,
  • Flat renewals after that, and because of this and our commitment to impeccable service…
  • Our clients remain with us an average of 12 years…an unheard of accomplishment in the health insurance industry.
×
…and state-of-the-art technology for painless administration and integration of services, we make your life easier.
No one thinks about making your life easier and more efficient than MBA Benefit Administrators. Our technological investments are totally integrated across services so that employees and employers – with HIPAA-compliant and appropriate need-to-know safeguards – can view at a glance their standing for benefits, claims, plan reporting and other services. These advancements provide:

A Comprehensive On-Line Enrollment Wizard: Employee self-enrollment or HR department enrollment methods, including ancillary program enrollments and billings.

HR On-line Capabilities: View, adjust and approve on-line employee eligibilities; check claims status, print reports and plan documents all from one place.

Multiple Employee Access Channels: Employees can view on-line their claims status, eligibility and account balances of reimbursement plans such as HRA, HSA, Flex and Executive Reimbursement plans. In addition, we offer all employees our MBA App, where they can:

  • Carry a virtual ID card,
  • Check on the status of a claim,
  • Submit secure documentation to MBA,
  • Contact our support team,
  • …and more!

On-line Document Management: In one place view specific documents such as:

  • Plan Documents
  • Temporary ID Cards, and
  • Employee Communications and Forms

HSA Services Integration: MBA seamlessly integrates HSA plans with HealthEquity Services. Claims information is electronically transferred from MBA’s claims system to HealthEquity employee accounts. There is no need for paper claim filing or second-guessing the eligibility of expenses. Even employee eligibility is updated through MBA data feeds.

HRA Reimbursement Plans: MBA’s administration processes allow clients and their participants to rely on accurate and timely processing of reimbursements. Eligibility, billing and remittance of claims, integrated scanning and storage allow for real-time remote access.

Section 125 Flexible Spending Plans: MBA Benefit Administrators coordinates with employers to offer Section 125 Flexible Spending administration and help employees save money on medical expenses. Providing this benefit for your employees is like getting a 30% discount on Medical Premiums, uncovered medical expenses and dependent care.

COBRA Administration: MBA Benefit Administrators can handle all of your COBRA requirements. We will mail and track notifications, coordinate COBRA payments, receipts and reporting and ensure claims match “paid through” dates, plus give you on-line access to all activities.

×
At MBA employers are cared for too…
MBA goes the extra mile to ensure that as an employer your health plan does not complicate your life. We give you things like:

  • Business intelligence for advanced reporting and critical analysis of your plan’s performance, costs, payouts, claims analysis and large claims submitted for insurance.
  • Billing and Funding services integrated with enrollment, customized to your specifications and handled electronically.
  • Account balancing systems produce cost accounting reports and perform bank reconciliation activities, available for review at any time.
  • And the ability to review multiple reports regarding your plan; check registers, active employee reports, YTD recaps, claims reviews and lots more.
×